Recessions may
differ in depth and length, but a recent
book —
This Time Is Different — Eight Centuries of
Financial Folly, by
Carmen N. Reinhart
and Kenneth S. Rogoff — finds no
significant difference in eight centuries of
financial folly. In each case, however,
those engaged were able to convince
themselves that their situation was unique.
For example,
there was a housing bubble (and banking
panic) in 1907 — a century before the
sub-prime crisis of 2008. Real housing
prices in the U.S. stayed below 75 percent
of the 2001 value for almost all the years
between1891 and 1977.
In 2007, there
was a 45 percent decline in U.S.
peak-to-trough real equity prices, lasting a
year. This compared with a historical
average of 55.9 percent, and a duration of
3.4 years.
Reinhart and
Rogoff are well-equipped to assess the
situation. Reinhart is the Dennis
Weatherstone Senior Fellow at the
Peterson Institute for International
Economics.
Previously, she was Professor of
Economics and
Director of the Center for International
Economics at the
University of Maryland.
Rogoff is currently the Thomas D. Cabot
Professor of Public Policy and Professor of
Economics at
Harvard University.
The U.S.
Federal Reserve faces a dilemma after two
rounds of quantitative easing — can it raise
interest rates to curb inflation without
dampening the still-fragile economic
recovery? As we face a step-up in inflation,
it is instructive to see that the inflation
rate around the world ran 20 percent or
higher between 1500 and 1790, 1800 to 1913,
and 1914 to 2008. In the United States,
between 1720 and 1791 for 7.6 percent of
years, the rate exceeded 20 percent, and 40
percent for four years.
Looking at past
cycles of unemployment and banking crises,
the historical average trough-to-peak
increase was 7 percent, with a duration of
4.8 years. In the United States, during the
Great Depression, unemployment was 22
percent for 4 years. In the present
recession, unemployment has exceeded 7
percent since December 2008.
Debt crises
involving sovereign default on debt have
been recurring. Before the 1930s, the
thinking was that there would never again be
a world war, and the 1920s were a period of
buoyant global optimism. But the market
crash in 1929 was followed by global
deflation and the largest wave of defaults
in history. Another round in the 1980s was
preceded by OPEC’s run-up in oil prices,
higher interest rates and a collapse in
commodity prices. Mexico defaulted in August
1983, followed by the default in a dozen
emerging markets including Argentina, Brazil
and Turkey. In the 1990s, Asia had a debt
crisis followed by Latin America in 1990s to
early 2000s.
Egypt defaulted
on external debt in 1984, when its ratio of
external debt to GDP was 112 percent. Today,
the European Community is grappling with how
to deal with Greece, where the debt to GDP
ratio was 140 percent in 2010, now spiraling
toward 170 percent. Last year’s €110 billion
bailout didn’t solve the problem and Greece
is seeing riots in the streets as it
attempts to impose austerity measures, while
preparing to ask for another bailout of €120
billion. There are calls for Greece to exit
the eurozone, as the euro weakens against
the dollar. Ireland and Portugal, which have
already received bailout packages from the
European Union and the International
Monetary Fund, and Spain may be facing a
similar prospect down the road.
This book is
very well documented and often mentioned by
panels of economists. It is highly
recommended.
This Time Is
Different — Eight Centuries of Financial
Folly, Carmen
N. Reinhart and Kenneth S. Rogoff, Princeton
University Press, 2009, $35.00.